Reading the scorecard
lesson 8 of 8Locked, then graded
Every pick freezes an hour before kickoff, with the market price as it stood at that moment, and is graded once the game is final. A locked pick is never edited, so the record cannot be improved after the fact.
Why the record alone misleads
Picking every favorite wins most college football games, so a strong record is the minimum, not the proof. The better questions: did picks win about as often as the model said, and how did the model do when it disagreed with the market?
College football, the season so far
Graded picks468–185wins–losses
Hit rate71.7%72.3% expected
Men's college basketball, the season so far
Graded picks675–148wins–losses
Hit rate82.0%83.9% expected